It's 2021, but this song deserves a music video

I JUST DISCOVERED THIS GROUP LIKE 10 MINS AGO AND I THINK THERE IS NO RETURN FROM THIS POINT

I remember being obsessed with this video when I found it 5 years ago because of the ending where everyone was laughing, screaming, just being normal Astro, I used to laugh along with them now I’m watching it with tears in my eyes. Rest in peace, Moonbin. ❤️‍🩹

과거로 가서 붙잡고... 싶다

Its not an ASTRO dance practice without the yelling and chaos at the end XD

when it comes to dance practices rocky is ur bias dont lie

지켜주지못해 미안해 빈아 널 사랑할 수 있게 가수 해줘서 고마워 영원히 기억할께

That's why astro is the only kpop group i stan for

I just realized how much they grew up since the debuted My eyes are sweating

This choreography will forever be the best choreography ever in the history of kpop!

빈아 널 보면서 진짜 아티스트가 이런거구나 깨달았어 처음 좋아해본 아이돌이 아스트로였고 마지막도 아스트로야 정말 최고였고 앞으로도 너희가 최고야❤ 빈아 사랑해 가수해줘서 고마워

2023...never imagine we lost binnie and Rocky would left.. Me crying over this video missing binnie and Rocky moment miss astro ot6..

Now I *really* want to know what the M/V would've been like if this is how beautiful the choreography is ;-;

The choreography is so fucking good. Seriously, I haven't seen a choreography this good and with a unique style like this since Infinite and Shinee.

내가 진짜 붙잡으러 가고싶어 진짜로 간절해 빈아

얼마나 괴로운지 지울 수가 없어 문빈아 니가 이렇게 떠나가니 💔😭😭

This song must be perfect if they drop it as a soundtrack in K-drama

can we talk about moonbin and rocky's double spin in the back 2:51? and eunwoo gliding across the stage

I can never forgive fantagio for not giving this song an MV that it deserved !!!

I've watched this choreography for a thousandth times and the LOW THE VOLUME still always kills me 🤣🤣🤣

Honestly I want to cry so hard. This dance practice seems so different from the other ones. From the dance to the song to the video itself. The dance is so powerful and full, like they're giving it their all. The song is so powerful as well, their vocals are off the charts, it really seems like they're trying to make this one memorable. To me this feels like if they were disbanding. The room itself isn't as bright as usual, it's kinda dim. Once they finished and they went close to the camera acting like themselves, it really felt like this was the end of this group, their final leave. I don't know, it's just me but I'm so glad that they're going to have many more amazing comebacks in the future

I have a feeling and my guts are never wrong. This guys will make it to the top. They will be huge in a couple of years. ( THAT is coming from someone that does not stan them)

Moonbin. Only someone with your performance ability can excel in the entire art of performing. First, it was your voice that mesmerized me and drew me towards you. You sing with such lightness and delicacy, but there is so much power behind every note that you sing. Your voice just gingerly glides through each word, but you have so much control and emotion at the same time. Your voice is capable of so much at one time and it is overwhelmingly beautiful to get to hear what you have to offer. You surprise us with each song because no two are the same and your voice just always seems to fit comfortably with the music. No Astro song is complete without the sweetness and airiness of your voice that can touch the hearts of Aroha in mere seconds. Your dancing style is so unique and passionate that I have a hard time believing that I have even discovered. The way that you naturally connect all of your moves together and complete each one with so much energy leaves me in awe and wonder. Somehow, your body speaks the language of dance and you just know how to move your body. Each little movement tells a story and every time that you get on stage, you build on that story with a performance that Aroha have never seen before. All you need is yourself and the music to completely leave a lasting impression on your audience. You are a natural-born performer and meant to be on stage. Every challenge that is thrown at you musically, you conquer it and seem to be able to perform with ease. I know you are completely in your element when you’re performing and I get this rush and excitement when you are on the stage, where you are meant to be. I am so glad you have decided to pursue that musical side in you and that you share that with your Aroha. It feels complete when you get to perform for us, and there is a side of you that we get to experience when you are ding so. Your love of performing and your ability to pour your heart into your music is one aspect of you that I love, but I’ve also fallen in love with your personality all the same. I first noticed your natural chemistry with your members. I always felt that I knew you by watching you, but you seem the most comfortable around your members and always act in such ways that I never expect! I love how easily that you laugh when you’re with them; even at the smallest of quips. In turn, you are always making your members laugh. At first, I thought that these moments were unexpected, but I’ve gotten so used to you all laughing so frequently at almost anything, and it brings me warmth and a joy I’ve never known elsewhere. I know that in order to be so open with someone, you have to have great trust and a strong bond, which is what you have with your members. I learned quickly that you can make your members laugh because of all of the hidden talents and gifts that you have. For example, the fact that you have a very strong sense of smell never fails to make your members laugh when it becomes apparent that you can smell something that they can’t. It’s in the little things that you’re able to find some reason to create laughter, which is, as I always say, one of the greatest gifts that you can provide for others. You always know when to have fun, but on top of that, I love how respectful that you are of your members. You are always so mindful of their feelings and are patient with them. You consider their opinions and ideas on different topics and always praise them whenever you have the chance. You work so well with them on a professional level, but your relationship goes beyond just friendship. You are one of the people that have allowed Astro to become a family, and you only deepen this relationship with every passing day. I know that the six of you have been together for a while, and your openness and honesty with the other members has established a warm and safe place for them to stay. No matter where you are, when you’re with them you can do anything. You’ve undoubtedly contributed the success of Astro, but more importantly, you are the reason that your members have grown to become who they are today. Every single second spent with them has been a reason for them to try harder and believe in themselves. It is so interesting to see how you’ve impacted each of them individually and beautiful to see them only become stronger and more sure of themselves. I love how selfless and loving you are to your members which is all that you can be for them; as you all are going along on this journey together. At the end of the day, you have them and they have you. I love that have created an environment of unwavering trust and pure love with your members. I can feel this love from my screen, even if I’m not with you in person. This speaks to how strong your relationship is. Similarly, you have built up a history of strong dedication to your Aroha. I know that you are sometimes disappointed because you can’t be there in the ways that you want to for Aroha all of the time. This hurts my heart because there is nothing more that Aroha could ever ask of you. Just being there and releasing even the smallest bit of content for us is enough to inspire us for a lifetime. We are so grateful for the hard work that you’ve put into to bring us any of the music, performances, or laughter that you’ve brought us. Again, we could never ask for more because you shower us in love just from the way that you talk to us. We are lucky to have you because you are always cheering us up and warming our hearts with your sweet actions and words. You never fail to put a smile on our faces and everything that you do for us is just perfect. We would never change anything and the life that you’re giving us right now is the greatest we could ever ask for. Overall, you are such a professional and kindhearted person. You are so gentle with those that you meet and sometimes it’s hard to believe that the same Moonbin that commands the stage is the same Moonbin that can sometimes be shy and sensitive. I love every part of your personality and know that I have grown to be more like you because I admire you so much. I want to sincerely thank your parents and family for raising you and helping you become the person that you are today. I know that your family is extremely important to you, and your Aroha keep them in our hearts as you do yours. We wouldn’t have you without their guidance, so we really appreciate them and value them as well. Moonbin, you are truly a gift to this world and I am so lucky to have discovered Astro when I did. It’s been three years since I’ve discovered you, and I haven’t been there since the beginning like I would have liked to, but being here now is enough. I couldn’t choose anybody else that I would rather support. You are so loyal and hardworking for those that count on you. You are naturally generous and always seem to want the best for others. You’re willing to help people achieve their dreams no matter how you have to do it. Astro knows all of the success and glory that it knows today because of your determination to keep aiming higher. You always say that you’re going to do better than before, no matter what it is that you’re referring to. Whether it be a performance, comeback, or anything else, you always keep your promise to your Aroha and yourself. As Aroha, we already think that you’re perfect and we could never ask more of you, but somehow you surprise us and come back even stronger than before. I know that Astro has been through a lot even before your debut. I could not be prouder of you that you are still going strong today, especially in the midst of a pandemic, and you are trying new things. You never stop creating and giving back to your Aroha even though we never did anything to deserve so much of your efforts. You are so strong to be here today, and to be there to comfort and motivate your members through all that you’ve gone through together speaks a lot to your character. I know that none of them would be as happy and bright without your love and support for them. We know that you are so giving and never hesitate to do anything to make somebody smile. Even the smallest of actions have gone a long way, and I only hope you know the power of the love that you spread among so many people. I am so thankful for all of the times you’ve spent working for Aroha when you could have been doing anything else. Thank you for the endless nights of practice, struggles you might have face, and sacrifices you’ve made to ensure that even one Aroha is happy. There are so many inspired and confident people all across world because of your belief in them and your countless acts of kindness. I hope that you know Aroha want nothing other than to give you back all that you’ve given us. There’s not enough time to do that, but we can start by loving and supporting you always. We will never leave your side! We are genuinely thankful for all of the memories that you’ve given us and we hope that we remain in your heart a safe place like you are for us. I pray that you and your loved ones stay safe, and always find happiness in your future. I hope that you never overwork yourself because you do more than we can ever ask for. Thank you for all that you do and for the person that your members and Aroha can turn to for anything. Happy birthday Moonbin, and we adore you so much!

This is the video that made me a kpop fan, an AROHA and a stan 6 years ago. To this day, it is my favorite ASTRO song along with Innocent Love. I just can't believe that some of these lyrics would haunt me now... now that you, Binnie, have become that star in the sky (4.19.23). My AROHA 💜 aches but l can console myself knowing that you are in a better place and hope you have found your peace. I will miss your vibrant smile, your puppycat eyes, your laughter, your teasing Sanha, your friendship with all the others - Eunwoo, Rocky, MJ and Jinjin, and performing onstage, your mellow voice, and the way you dance that is my gold standard. You will always shine real bright, dear Binnie, even as the Moon meets the stars... 🤩. #Moonbin #ASTRO #MoonbinWeLoveYou

I am an army and moa. I used to say I'll never stan any other group aside from BTS and TXT. I never knew I needed Astro until I accidentally clicked Blue Flame. And here I am now, binge watching all their MVs, funny moments, Vlive. And I must admit, Astro has one of the best choreographies in Kpop.

! Oh no... Sanha got me feeling so attacked... Thought I was ready for a fierce concept but Idk anymore 😂 #HAPPYSANHADAY

no but korean music need this genre right now

how can i listen to my favourite song the same way anymore

WTF 😳😳 did Rocky and Moonbin just do a freakin double pirouette into axel ? At 2:53 Lol

me: *skips back every 5 seconds so I can look at a different member because they're all talented individuals who are skilled at dancing*

Arohas need this MV. 🙏

If Astro will make a remaster album i hope they can make MV for this song...

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS 1) Is this their comeback? Yes. ASTRO has been doing a seasonal concept throughout their first year (spring up, summer vibes, autumn story) and this is the title song of the winter album, Winter Dream. 2) When did they release an album? Winter Dream was released on February 22, 2017, one day before their first anniversary. This was most likely planned so that the "winter" comeback happened before the anniversary of the Spring album so they could come full circle with the concept. 3) Why does Winter Dream only have 3 songs? ASTRO did not end Autumn Story promotions until well into January. Winter Dream is titled a "special album", most likely because there was not enough time before the anniversary to create a mini album. However, the fact that ASTRO wrote lyrics to a song and title it "You&Me (Thanks AROHA)", a fan song, definitely makes up for the fact that there are only three songs. 4) Why aren't they promoting? How come I am just now hearing of this? They did not promote on music shows like groups typically do when they have a comeback. The release of the album was February 22 for the reason explained above. On February 26 they held two concerts for their Korean fans. On February 12, they traveled to Thailand to hold on a concert that had been rescheduled from October 2016. On February 28, they performed in Taiwan. On March 3, they performed in Hong Kong. On March 5, they performed in Singapore. Because of all of these concerts, they were unable to promote their song on music shows. Additionally, they've been working non stop all year round and fantagio probably wanted them to rest more during this time period and work on preparing a full album for the future. 5) Is there a music video? There is not. Although it was reported that a music video was filmed, the company released a statement saying that the footage was unsatisfactory and did not fit Astros image, and after much discussion astro and their management decided not to release anything. 6) Why do I also see it called "Should Have Held On To You" / "Should Have Held On" / "Should've Held On" / "Should've Held On To You"? Many of Astros tweets only used the hangul for the songs title, and fans did their best to translate the title. This dance practice is probably the first time many Aroha are seeing "again" as the official title. EDIT: ASTRO's official facebook did use the #Again when posting the highlight medley, but the title was not widely spread amongst AROHA and most still refer to it as "Should Have Held On To You". If you are looking for fancams, try searching Should Have Held On To You! if there are any other questions, please ask !!

before dis they used to wore pink green yellow shirt but now they wore black&white xD astro manly concept has comes out 😍

I'm back again, one of my fav dance practices

Soo heartbreaking, the reason ASTRO very different with the other group. They bring classic pop become modern style and make many people dont know about kpop like me being an aroha.

I haven't seen such in-sync choreo since Infinite DAMN SLAY ASTRO YALL GOT ME SNATCHED

2019 WHO'S STILL MAD THAT THIS SONG DOESN'T HAVE MUSIC VIDEO? edit: it's already 2020... *where's the mv?*

If only I can like this video everytime I rewatch it.

April 2021, ALL YOURS ERA and still waiting for the music video of this song..

AS A DANCER I AM JEALOUS OF ROCKY AND MOONBIN'S DOUBLE INTO AN AXLE UPDATE: BC ITS SO SOLID AND PROBABLY CONSISTENT LIKE GOALS

I swear Astro's choreos are the hardest but their songs are the easiest to sing

Still one of my favorite Astro choreos. Because why not?

This never gets old.... Still the best and FAVV...❤️

They performed it at Kcon and the audience loved it! Lots of people attending Kcon on Twitter said this song made them want to check Astro out!!!!

ASTRO needs more attention! They are so good. They have good choreos, their songs are beautiful. But they are so underrated! We must support them more! WE MUST REACH MORE VIEWS!

*Now no matter what song I listen to everything just hits really hard and I relate to everything*

They're so scary with their synchronization.. you know, this is just a random thought, but I want just a KPOP group to go onto America's Got Talent as just like a joke, right? But then they just blow the judges out of the water with their singing and dancing. It'd be the best prank ever, man, especially if the group is a lesser known one or one that's just recently debuted

Proud to say that ASTRO introduced me to K-pop and they still are my number 1 !!😍

omg eunwoo took aroha's advice of wearing white dress shirt from jinjin's birthday vapp

It doesnt matter how many years have passed, im always coming back to this perfect dance practice

The most satisfying choreography ever, THEY'RE SO SYNCHRONIZED

this song is SO meaningful from the start Until the end. Like You will burst into tears whenever the Chorus will play. I NOTICED THAT MJ DIDNT COME NEAR THE CAMERA AND DID HIS VERY BRIGHT SMILE. Im so sad. Whenever Im listening in this song I cant stop repeating it unti the end of the day. THIS SONG IS TOTALLY MY STYLE. I THINK OTHERS TOO. HUHU. i think Fantagio will Regret this for not having an MV but I still love ASTRO CUTE STYLE. BUT THIS ONE IS SO AMAZING. AROHA'S WILL BE WITH ASTRO FOREVER. WERE HOPING THAT MORE COMEBACKS WILL COME. LOVE YOU GUYS

OMOO I'M CRYING

Still the best choreography of the 21st century

Reason why i get into kpop, i miss you 6

I've watched this video a million times since it was uploaded and I'm sill blown away by how much talent each of them has 😓

Kings of synchronization, no cap

The way I’ll never be over this

I'm a Moomoo + Roha of 2021. To whoever subbed this, thank you! I'm an earphone user, you saved my precious ear buds. HAHAHA. Stan talent, stan Astro.

I want them to get big but at the same time I want them to be my little secret... it's really selfish of me to ask it though They deserve to be seen

Who is here in 2020? This is literally my favorite Astro Song😭😍😍😍❤️❤️❤️

I still can't get over this 🥺

보고싶다 내 사랑들.. 보고파 빈아 ㅠㅠㅠ

rocky never fails to amaze no matter how many times i watch him dance, his moves are so smooth and sharp, he inspires me to be as good as him

Hoping that: 1. Astro will continue their dancing skills and be the second Infinite with their knife choreography and practice more for their vocal skills and become the second btob, 2. Become big like BTS and slay charts until there's nothing left to be slayed, 3. Become popular in korea and internationally, 4. Have a big and loyal fandom, and lastly, 5. Win a Daesang in MAMA's. Maybe not today nor tomorrow, but maybe soon.

GONNA PRACTICE THE CHOREOGRAPHY OF THIS

I never stan any kpop group before but because of true beauty ,Cha Eun Woo☺💜 I was given the chance to know the group Astro, and I am madly in love with their moves, choreography,faces, voice , attitude ,etc. They have an amazing talent. They deserve to be on top☺💜 My boys ☺💜 My happy pill☺💜 Thanks God💜 I found ASTRO💜 Proud Aroha here from Cebu,the Philippines☺💜

i dont really get it why they dont release an mv for this... everything is so perfect.

아스트로 춤 중에 이게젤멋짐

One of the best choreographies of all time. Legendary!

AGAIN IS THE BEST ASTRO SONG, PERIOD

I'm really not into kpop but Eun woo brought me to astro and there's no turning back now..i'm already inlove with these cute dorks..the only group i stan..fighting!! 😊😘

idk why they arent promoting this cause everything about this, from the song itself to the choreo to the boys, is absolutely stunning and beautiful and I feel like not promoting this masterpiece is kind of a waste. @ Fantagio what the heck?

It's almost 2022, but this is still one of the best song and dance.

Your kpop fan life is not complete if you haven't seen this Astro satisfying videos and choreography! Believe meeeee

I'M JEALOUS OF SANHA, HE LOOKS LIKE a '97 liner HUHU HE'S HOT, HE DOESN'T LOOKS LIKE A BABY (he doesnt looks like '00 liner) IN THIS DANCE PRACTICE 😭😭😭

New Aroha: So who's their visual line?? me: Ughh Its Mj, Jinjin, Enwoo, Moonbin, Rocky and Sanha :D noob: ughh isnt that all of them?? me: yea CUZ ASTRO IS A VISUAL GROUP

Me when watching Astro MV or dance practice for the first time: 1st view: focus on the lyrics and the overall of the MV 2nd view: focus on the choreography 3rd view: focus on Rocky's way of dancing 4th view: focus on my biases MJ and Sanha

❤❤ I really miss you Moon Bin😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢

I DON'T EVEN KNOW ASTRO THAT WELL BUT I'M STILL CRYING? WHY?? GOD Those boys are SO GOOD AND PRECIOUS PLEASE SOMEONE tell me what to watch to get to know them!

why are they so underrated, i mean like they didn't get enough attention while they're so talented and their songs are all good whyyyyy???

Daily comment crying about how this song has amazing vocals, amazing musical arrangements, amazing choreography but we were robbed from having an MV

Every time I see this it still amazes me !! The synchronization is amazing !! ASTRO sync kings

can i just say that Sanhas legs are like fucking goals

People talking about how pity it is for astro for not releasing a mv for this song. i just want to say.. I AGREE WITH YOU TOO OMG. AND THEY SHOULD ACTUALLY PROMOTE THIS SONG. WHY DIDN FANTAGIO DID IT. WHY.

im a stay but astro's albums really are no skips especially the all light album i wish more people would listen to astro's discography because it is IMMACULATE

Astro is no.1 kpop for me..♥️💕

i clicked this by accidently and i LOVE IT AND THERES NO MV WHAT??

Applaud to the translator who said LOW THE VOLUME

빈아.. 아직도 믿기지가 않아.. 누구보다 반짝이던 니가 진짜 별이 됐다니... 티비틀면 바로 나올것 같은데...진짜 믿을수기 없다.

Best choreography.

ok real talk: no matter how surface-level impressed i get with a song, video, or group, i've never actually connected with a group besides BTS enough to properly stan them. However, i'm like 4 hours deep into an Astro binge (i just found them) and i tried so hard to resist (cause i don't have the emotional energy to stan another group tbh hahah) but *it's h a p p e n i n g* like fuck they're so funny and talented and i'm already so soft for them. I've just been grinning for the past 4 hours cause they're such goons. I know their names already so it's basically too late to back out now. I'm in it, guys. I stan.

BUT I LIVE FOR SANHA'S RIPPED JEANS BRUH

THIS SONG DESERVES A MUSIC VIDEO!!! 😩💜😭

"So where's gonna be the dance break?" Astro: Yes Lmao, I still feel proud when I see people react to this. And yes, I'm also watching this on 2021

Rocky is so damn hypnotizing. I kept trying to pay attention to everyone else but my eyes would always stay on Rocky (not complaining)

honestly I'm just amazed that they do a double pirouette into an axel turn to the ground. That's some pretty advanced contemporary dance technique there!

It's 2022, but this song deserves a music video

I'm stopping by after 6 years since I last commented. I watch this now and cry for a very different reason. Hell, I barely started the video and as soon as the music started and I heard Moonbin's voice, I just lost it. I've been with Astro for as long as predebut. I'll forever miss Moonbin so much.